Families who lose a loved one in a preventable accident face immediate financial pressure from funeral costs, lost household income, medical bills from final treatment, and insurance companies pushing for quick closures. One of the first questions surviving spouses, children, and parents ask is: “What is a wrongful death case worth?” The search for an “average” settlement amount is understandable, but Pennsylvania wrongful death cases vary so widely in value that no single number provides meaningful guidance.
Pennsylvania law divides wrongful death claims into two separate actions: the Wrongful Death Act claim, which compensates surviving family members for their losses, and the Survival Action, which recovers damages the decedent experienced before death. Settlement amounts depend on the decedent’s age, earning capacity, family structure, the strength of liability evidence, available insurance coverage, and whether the claim settles before trial or proceeds to a verdict.
Pennsylvania’s Wrongful Death Act (42 Pa. C.S. § 8301) creates a statutory cause of action when a person dies due to another’s wrongful act, neglect, or default. The claim belongs to the decedent’s estate and must be filed by the personal representative named in the estate proceedings.
Only certain family members may recover damages under the Act, and Pennsylvania law establishes a strict hierarchy of beneficiaries. Surviving spouses, children, and parents recover damages for their own losses caused by the death. If the decedent left a spouse or children, parents cannot recover. If no spouse, children, or parents survive, siblings or other heirs under Pennsylvania intestacy law may recover, though these more distant relatives face practical challenges proving financial dependency or close relationships.
The personal representative files the claim on behalf of all beneficiaries, consolidating their interests into a single action. Individual family members cannot file separate wrongful death lawsuits; Pennsylvania law requires one unified claim managed by the estate representative.
The Wrongful Death Act compensates family members for their losses, not the decedent’s suffering. Recoverable damages include:
The Wrongful Death Act does not allow recovery for the decedent’s own pain, suffering, or medical expenses before death. Those damages fall under the separate Survival Action.
The Survival Action (42 Pa. C.S. § 8302) preserves the decedent’s personal-injury claim, allowing the estate to recover damages the decedent could have pursued if they had survived. This claim compensates the estate, and ultimately the heirs under the will or intestacy law, for harm the decedent experienced before death.
Damages that the deceased suffered from the accident that can be recovered include:
The Survival Action does not cover losses that occurred after death; those belong to the Wrongful Death Act. The estate recovers survival damages, which then pass to heirs through probate according to the decedent’s will or Pennsylvania intestacy law if no will exists.
Pennsylvania allows personal representatives to file wrongful death and survival claims in the same lawsuit, consolidating all damages into one proceeding. This combined approach produces more comprehensive recovery than pursuing either claim alone because each action covers different categories of harm.
Defendants and insurers sometimes dispute which damages belong to which claim, particularly when medical expenses and funeral costs overlap or when calculating the appropriate allocation of settlement funds between estate beneficiaries and wrongful death beneficiaries. Without careful documentation and legal analysis, families risk accepting settlements that undervalue one claim while focusing on the other.
Courts routinely adjudicate both actions together to avoid duplicative litigation, conflicting verdicts, and inconsistent damage awards. Consolidation also benefits families by reducing legal costs, streamlining discovery, and presenting a unified narrative to the jury about how the defendant’s negligence caused both the decedent’s suffering and the family’s ongoing losses.
Marcus & Mack structures wrongful death cases to pursue both claims simultaneously from the outset. We gather medical records documenting the decedent’s treatment, pain levels, consciousness, and final days to build the survival claim. We obtain employment records, tax returns, household budgets, and family testimony to quantify wrongful death damages. We coordinate with the estate’s personal representative to maintain proper standing for both actions and work with vocational economists, life-care planners, and medical experts who calculate the present value of lost earnings, household services, and future support.
Settlement value turns on the decedent’s economic and non-economic contributions to the family, the strength of liability evidence, the defendant’s insurance coverage, and the jurisdiction’s jury verdict history. Key factors include:
Available insurance coverage plays a significant role in wrongful death settlement negotiations. Wrongful death claims may draw on multiple insurance policies depending on the circumstances of the death. Wrongful death damages may be paid from policies like the:
When all available insurance coverage is exhausted and damages exceed policy limits, families face the question of pursuing the defendant’s personal assets. Pennsylvania law allows judgment creditors to execute against personal assets to satisfy wrongful death judgments, but practical recovery remains limited in most cases. For these reasons, identifying and pursuing available insurance coverage represents the most reliable path to recovery in wrongful death cases.
Documentation that proves the decedent’s economic contributions, family relationships, and the defendant’s liability increases settlement leverage and counters insurer arguments for reduced payouts. Key evidence includes:
Gathering and organizing this evidence early in the case strengthens negotiating position and prevents insurers from minimizing the decedent’s contributions or questioning causation.
Marcus & Mack works with families to collect comprehensive documentation, consult appropriate experts, and present evidence in demand letters and settlement negotiations that reflect the scope of the family’s loss under Pennsylvania law.
Pennsylvania imposes a two-year statute of limitations measured from the date of death (42 Pa. C.S. § 5524). If the decedent survived weeks or months after the injury before dying, the two-year deadline runs from the death date, not the injury date.
The wrongful death claim does not arise until death occurs. If the decedent survived for days, weeks, or months after the injury, the survival action covers the period from injury to death, while the wrongful death claim covers losses after death. The two-year statute of limitations for wrongful death begins at death, but the survival action’s two-year period begins at the injury date.
Wrongful death damages for loss of support, loss of companionship, and funeral expenses are generally not taxable under federal or Pennsylvania law, nor are Survival Action damages for pain and suffering. Portions compensating for lost interest or punitive damages may be taxable. Consult a tax professional about your specific settlement.
Yes. Pennsylvania’s modified comparative-negligence rule reduces wrongful death settlements by the decedent’s percentage of fault, provided their fault stays below 51%. If the decedent was 51% or more at fault, no recovery is available.
Wrongful death damages paid directly to beneficiaries do not pass through probate, but survival action damages belong to the estate and are distributed to heirs through probate. Funeral expenses reimbursed under the wrongful death claim also pass through the estate.
Marcus & Mack wrongful death attorneys work on contingency, meaning no upfront fees and no payment unless your family recovers compensation. We offer free consultations at all five locations.
Robert S. Marcus Personal Injury Attorney in Pennsylvania
Losing a loved one to someone else’s negligence causes financial and legal uncertainties at the worst possible moment. You shouldn’t have to navigate Pennsylvania’s wrongful death statutes, negotiate with insurance adjusters, or calculate damages while mourning your loss.
Marcus & Mack represents families pursuing wrongful death and survival claims throughout Central and Western Pennsylvania. Our five offices in Indiana (PA), State College, DuBois, Altoona, and Johnstown serve families who need local access backed by experienced wrongful death advocacy.
Bring any documentation you have to your free consultation, and let our team evaluate your claim with the care and attention your family deserves.
Marcus & Mack
